Notes · James Andrew Smith

Bell curves in bell curves

The post

CREATIVE DIRECTION: a thought.

There are bell curves in bell curves.

Luxury sits on the tail of a big fashion curve, and it has a curve of its own. Its own tail is tiny: 0.2% of clients make up 24% of all luxury spending.

They are also the people who know the name of the creative director. 68 in 100, against 44 in 100 aspirational clients.

Now, fashion is an interesting intersection of art and business; that’s what drew me in the first place. Traditionally, the idea of that “little tail” all the way to the right was that it would, for sure, sell a few couture pieces, but more importantly, set a tone and directionality that would lead to sales of ready-to-wear (middle of the little bell), and that in turn would drive aspirational sales of handbags and the like at the middle of the big bell.

So a house that neuters its creative direction (my only best guess as to what may be happening) and aims its design at the middle of the luxury curve, hoping to reach the middle of the big one, is frankly more likely to land at the tasteless other end of the curve... it all shifts left.

...craft is an interesting word in this conversation. I keep struggling with why crafting animation has relevance to fashion. I mean, fashion illustration with Augustine was my favorite class at London College of Fashion, and illustration is a wonderful way to share creative expression. However, I don’t think it necessarily conveys “craft” that is particularly relevant to the product. Feels a lot more like “signal”, or the cynic in me that understands most of these groups are part of large conglomerates, sees an enormous earned media play in everything about the move...

I think we are overdue for some deeply out of sync creativity, a punk moment... just me?

First published on LinkedIn, 6 November 2026.

The cards

Diagram titled Bell curves in bell curves. A wide bell curve filled with cyan dots represents the whole market; its far right tail is shaded magenta and circled. An inset redraws that tail at its own scale as a magenta bell curve, with its own small yellow tail at the right. Labeled as a diagram, not measured data.
Card 1 of 5
Chart titled 0.2% of clients, 24% of spend. A grid of 100 dots, 24 filled magenta: Top Tier clients, who spend over 50,000 euros a year, are 0.2% of luxury consumers and account for 24% of all luxury spending in 2025. Source: BCG-Altagamma True-Luxury Global Consumer Insights 2026.
Card 2 of 5
Chart titled Who knows the creative director. Two grids of 100 dots: 68 filled for Top Tier clients and 44 filled for aspirational clients, the share who say they know who the creative director of the brands they buy is. Source: BCG-Altagamma 2026, 10,000 consumers in 11 markets.
Card 3 of 5
List titled 25 changes at the top: creative director changes at major fashion houses from January 2024 to November 2026, grouped by year, including Chanel, Gucci, Dior, Loewe, Saint Laurent, McQueen, and Balenciaga twice.
Card 4 of 5
Chart titled More original, more alike. In a 2024 Science Advances study by Doshi and Hauser, writers who could ask for AI ideas wrote stories rated 8.1% more original, while their stories became 8.9% more similar to one another, measured as a share of the range of similarity scores.
Card 5 of 5

Contact

Tell us about your next stores.

Book a Store Walk